As seen in Law360’s “Justices Blast Fed. Circ. Patent Indefiniteness Test”
Law360 reports on the recent oral arguments before the Supreme Court in Nautilus Inc. v. Biosig Instruments Inc., a case that concerns the standard used by courts in determining whether a patent is invalid for indefiniteness. The standard currently applied by the Federal Circuit is that a patent is indefinite if it is "insolubly ambiguous" or "not amenable to construction." The parties and the Supreme Court justices apparently agreed that the Federal Circuit’s formulation sets too low a bar in terms of the definiteness required of patent claims. It remains to be seen, however, how the Supreme Court will adjust the standard.
According to Kaye Scholer Partner Aaron Stiefel, Co-Chair of the firm’s Intellectual Property Department, “It was clear that the ‘insolubly ambiguous’ test had little support and that the justices are searching for a new standard that is more workable without leaving many patents open to being found indefinite.”
"Everybody all around the room recognized that the current formulation may be too strong and is not likely to survive the Supreme Court," he said, noting that the court will likely "articulate a more centrist kind of standard."
Also of Interest
- Law360 Names Blank a 2016 Intellectual Property MVP December 7, 2016 • Recognitions
- Second Circuit Expands Split on Nominative Fair Use November 16, 2016 • Articles
- JUVE Handbuch Recommends Frankfurt Office and Lawyers November 14, 2016 • Recognitions
- US News–Best Lawyers Recognizes 32 Kaye Scholer Practices and 41 Lawyers November 1, 2016 • Recognitions
- Maier Plans Emergency Response with Fort Meade and Fort Detrick Commanders October 20, 2016 • Client Successes
- Winning the War: Strategies for Prevailing in Consumer Fraud and False Advertising... October 17, 2016 • Articles
- 3D Printing: New Legal Issues Emerge with the Technology’s Revolutionary Potential October 10, 2016 • Articles
- Consumer Products in the Age of Big Data October 4, 2016 • Articles
- Shape of Things to Come: Protecting Product Configuration and Packaging Design September 26, 2016 • Articles